Repeating that the operations will be conducted in accordance with international law will not make it so. The international law referred to seems to include only the principle of territorial sovereignty. International human rights law is not mentioned, and the fact that migrants have rights not acknowledged.
Panic time is the worst time for making structural decisions with a long-term vision.
Indeed, what we are witnessing is a fire sale of everything that made the EU a “common territory”.
It is now clear that NATO will be used to push back migrants from Greece to Turkey. Greece was deemed not a safe country for Dublin refugee returns after the European Court of Human Rights MSS decision, and push backs to Libya were condemned by the Hirsi decision. Yet, it now seems perfectly acceptable to everyone that refugees will be pushed back from Greek waters to Turkey.
Under the government’s tough immigration policy, asylum-seekers who try to reach Australia by boat are sent to detention camps in the Pacific island nations of Papua New Guinea and Nauru. They are blocked from being resettled in Australia even if found to be refugees. […]
“Doctors must expect to advocate for their patients,” Doctors For Refugees co-founder Richard Kidd, who has joined the vigil outside the hospital, said.
“We have … overwhelming evidence over many years now that detention does terrible harm to babies and children, particularly their mental health but also physical health.” – The Japan Times, February 14, 2016
Militarisation of border control, such as the deployment of NATO ships to the Aegean sea, is the worst idea possible, considering that migrants are perfectly innocent and innocuous persons in their vast majority, and that “fighting the smugglers” is a red herring: as long as persons in need of mobility will not be provided with official mobility solutions, unofficial mobility solutions will be provided by opportunistic smuggling rings. The only way to actually eliminate smuggling is to take over their market by offering legal, safe and cheap mobility solutions, with all the identity and security checks that efficient visa procedures can provide.
The operationalization of such a military operation remains to be outlined. What will NATO do that Frontex didn’t do? When intercepting a migrant boat, what will the procedure be? Will they embark migrants on their navy ships as the Italians did in Mare Nostrum? If not, What? If they do, where will they disembark them? Turkey? Greece? To what authority will they transfer them? How will simple pushbacks be prevented? How will they treat the migrants on board? How will they identify protection needs?
In December 2015, the British street artist Banksy revealed an artwork in the refugee camp of Calais. The graffiti depicted the founder of Apple, Steve Jobs, with a black bin bag thrown over one shoulder, and meant to point out that Jobs was the son of a Syrian migrant who went to the United States after the second world war. More recently, Banksy criticised the use of teargas in “the Jungle” of Calais with a new artwork on the French embassy in London. The work depicted the young girl from Les Misérables with tears in her eyes.
Ai Weiwei, the Chinese artist and activist, also used art as a way to raise awareness. He recently recreated the image of Aylan Kurdi, the infant whose body was tragically washed up on a Turkish beach and who instantly became the symbol of the plight of refugees from Syria.